What's a Carnival?

By Mrs. Accountability on October 9th, 2008

I remember a few months after I started blogging I started hearing about blog carnivals. The blog that inspired me to start Out of Debt Again was Mr. Debtbeater. He wrote about entering some carnivals and I was so curious. IIRC, I wrote to him privately and asked how carnivals worked. He was very helpful with information and I started looking around for myself. It felt like entering a whole new area of the Internet. Knowing what I know now, I am not sure why I felt so intimidated, but I sure do remember feeling lost. I tested the waters in April with my first ever submission to the Festival of Frugality. I was accepted and what a boost of confidence that gave me. Thank you Aaron Stroud for including me back in April.

It’s really not hard to get started. But I remember not knowing where to look for these carnivals, and not too sure how to enter. In case you are where I was several months ago, I’d like to share what I’ve learned.

Follow The Rules

Here are a few generic rules to be aware of (each carnival has its own set of guidelines):

Read the rules for submission carefully
Follow the rules
Submit an appropriate post to the carnival you are entering
Submit early rather than at the last minute (this makes it easier on the host if you can remember)
When the carnival is posted, announce on your blog that you’ve been accepted for submission at XYZ carnival, with a link to the hosting blog
I also like to go into the post I’ve submitted (where it’s at on my blog) and make a little welcome note at the top to welcome new readers from the carnival (see the introductory comment on this post for an example) as well as thank the host for including my submission
Thank the host via the comments of the carnival post on the host’s site
Submit the carnival to social bookmarking sites (Digg, Delicious, Stumbleupon, Facebook, Mixx, Twitter)
Most carnivals accept one post per week
Some carnivals ask that you post exclusively to their carnival (for example, don’t enter the same post at every carnival you can find)
Make a special post for the week listing your posts in the various carnivals, and at the same time, link to two or three other posts in the carnival that you enjoyed reading. This way we all help each other out to promote our articles at the carnivals.

Personal Finance Carnivals

These are the carnivals that are on my radar. There are others, I just haven’t learned about all of them yet! These I’ve listed are in no specific order.

The Carnival of Debt Reduction – Monday
At the Carnival of Debt Reduction you will check the schedule page to learn all about this carnival. You’ll find on the schedule page a little blurb of what a carnival is, what kind of posts are appropriate for The Carnival of Debt Reduction, when your post needs to be submitted and you can also see the list of blogs that will be hosting this carnival. Next be sure to read the Rules for this carnival. When you’ve read all the instructions and you feel you have an appropriate post, go to the rules page and submit your article . The Carnival of Debt Reduction comes out on Monday mornings.

Carnival of Money Stories II – Monday
The original owner of the Carnival of Money Stories is missing in action and Adam of Money Relationship has decided to resurrect it. For the Carnival of Money Stories II you’ll want to first visit the submission page to learn the submission rules. There are five rules, and one is very important. In order to be accepted into this carnival, your submission must be a money STORY or experience . As with most carnivals, the Carnival of Money Stories travels from blog to blog each week. Check the schedule to see where this carnival is headed next. Click on the submission link at top to submit your article. This carnival goes up on Monday mornings.

Carnival of Personal Finance – Monday
From the main page, you’ll want to visit the about page to learn a bit about the Carnival of Personal Finance and what the carnival will accept for submissions. Check the schedule to see where the carnival is being hosted next. Read the Guidelines for Submission carefully and follow the rules. This page also asks you to be sure to link your blog to the carnival where your submission was accepted. This gives the carnival publicity. I also like to go to each blog hosting the carnival where my post was accepted and thank the host for including my post, as well as acknowledging the hard work they’ve done to host the carnival. It’s not manual labor, but it does take time and effort to put the carnival together and post it on time! This carnival goes out on Monday mornings.

Festival of Frugality – Tuesday
Read about the FoF on the about page. From the about page you can also find the submission guidelines, and the schedule. The FoF stresses that your post should be somewhere on the topic of frugality, so bear that in mind as you choose a post to submit. On the submission guidelines page, you’ll find the link to submit your post. Most of the carnivals seem to use Blog Carnival, which also freaked me out the first time I used it. For one thing it reloads after you type in your post’s URL, because it’s looking for it. But the screen goes blank and you have to scroll down to find what you’ve already entered. Then there’s the trackback URL and I still haven’t figured out what that is. Just leave it blank and you’ll be fine. The FoF comes out on Tuesday mornings.

Money Hacks Carnival – Wednesday
I just recently found this carnival, just last week in fact. I joined Money Hackers Network, and Pinyo emailed me and invited me to participate in the Money Hacks Carnival. The main page to the Money Hacks Carnival includes the schedule and the submission guidelines. The Money Hacks Carnival comes out on Wednesday mornings.

Carnival of Pecuniary Delights – Thursday

The carnival of Pecuniary Delights is a little different than the other carnivals in that there is no time limitation on submitting your post. Be sure to read the Submission Guidelines. The Carnival of Pecuniary Delights comes out on Thursday mornings.

Make It From Scratch Carnival – Tuesday

I found this carnival when Funny About Money hosted it back in September. While not exactly a personal finance carnival, it can help you save money if you make it yourself! The Make It From Scratch Carnival Guidelines are here, and this page also includes the day you need to submit your post to have it show up in the next carnival. The Make It From Scratch Carnival comes out on Tuesday mornings. Submission deadline: Sunday – check with current host to see if there is a time for deadline as well. I’ve seen some that cut off submissions at 5pm EST.

Road to Financial Independence Carnival hosted exclusively at One Family’s Blog – 3rd Monday of every month

I happened upon this carnival today (November 30, 2009) and it’s up to the 13th edition. Please make sure your posts are relevant.

Why Participate in Carnivals?

You might be asking yourself, “Why would I want to participate in a carnival?” Well, for one thing it’s a way to introduce yourself to the personal finance world. Most personal finance bloggers check out these carnivals, participate in them regularly, and host them. It’s a great way to announce your arrival in the blogging community.

After you get your feet wet by participating in a few carnivals, you’ll want to try hosting one. The first carnival I ever hosted was the Festival of Frugality #130. It was fun and wow, talk about traffic, hosting a carnival really brings a lot of new visitors! Most carnivals want you to submit a post to the carnival before you can host, so get to submitting if you are anxious to host. There are rules for hosting, too, which I did not cover in this post. Oh, and because you MUST read every submission, you end up meeting a lot of new people, too!

Speaking of hosting, I’m honored to be hosting the Carnival of Money Stories #80 in a few days on October 14, 2008.

If you found this post to be helpful, please comment and let me know! And let me know when you submit to your first carnival!

Yours Truly,